Menu of The Creamery - New Port Richey in New Port Richey, Florida, USA

Menu Overview

The Creamery in New Port Richey is a true gem for ice cream lovers seeking an authentic, handcrafted experience. Nestled at 9826 Little Rd, this local favorite delivers flavors that capture the essence of both classic and inventive ice cream creations. From the very first scoop, it becomes clear that this shop takes pride in quality ingredients and rich, creamy texture.

Among the standout flavors, the Mint Chocolate Chip and the Baileys ice cream shine brilliantly. The Mint Chip offers a refreshing, cool mint taste balanced perfectly with generous chocolate chunks, a classic done right. The Baileys flavor brings a subtle warmth and smoothness that elevates the tasting experience, ideal for those who appreciate a grown-up twist on traditional ice cream.

Another must-try is the Old Fashioned Cherry Vanilla, which evokes nostalgia with its vibrant cherry undertones layered over creamy vanilla. For those who enjoy pairing dairy with rich toppings, the Vanilla Ice Cream with Hot Chocolate is a comforting blend of warmth and sweetness that satisfies on cooler days or as a decadent treat. Fresh Made Strawberry Ice Cream notably stands out, bursting with natural fruit flavor and freshness, avoiding any artificial aftertaste.

Popular crowd-pleasers like Oreo and Frappuccino flavors showcase the shop’s versatility, appealing to a range of palates from kids to adults. Customer feedback highlights the unmatched quality — Nate, a self-proclaimed family ice cream connoisseur, praises their chocolate peanut butter flavor as “out of this world,” while Michelle Brooks Coats found the Cookie Monster flavor to be a delightful surprise with every spoonful. Shawn O’Connell’s emphasis on the Creamery being “the real deal” and the best ice cream in Pasco County echoes the consistent excellence felt by many patrons.

The atmosphere complements the menu wonderfully: clean, friendly, and inviting. Conversations with the owner reveal a genuine passion for crafting perfect ice cream and an unwavering dedication to customer satisfaction. This personal touch enriches the overall experience, making each visit feel welcoming and unique.

In essence, The Creamery - New Port Richey offers more than just ice cream; it delivers a sensory journey through thoughtfully curated flavors, excellent textures, and heartfelt service. Whether you’re sampling the banana pudding on a crispy waffle cone—as shared by another enthusiastic visitor—or indulging in salted peanut butter cookie or Kit Kat varieties, the quality and care are undeniable. For anyone in or visiting New Port Richey, a stop here is not just recommended; it’s essential.